N※N

US moves to restrict Mexican airlines over cargo, competition concerns

US Escalates Aviation Dispute with Mexico, Proposes Restrictions on Airlines Amid Cargo Operations Clash

In a significant escalation of tensions between the United States and Mexico over aviation policies, the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) has announced plans to impose restrictions on Mexican airlines, potentially barring them from expanding their services to American destinations. This move comes in direct response to Mexico's controversial decision to ban cargo flights from Mexico City's bustling Benito Juárez International Airport (AICM), a policy that has drawn sharp criticism from U.S. carriers and logistics firms. The proposed restrictions, if implemented, could disrupt cross-border air travel, affect passenger routes, and further strain bilateral relations in the aviation sector, which is a critical component of North American trade and tourism.

The core of the dispute revolves around Mexico's efforts to alleviate severe congestion at AICM, one of the busiest airports in Latin America. In late 2023, the Mexican government, under President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, issued a decree prohibiting all-cargo operations at AICM effective February 2024. The aim was to redirect these flights to the newer Felipe Ángeles International Airport (AIFA), located about 30 miles north of Mexico City. Proponents of the policy argue that it will reduce overcrowding at AICM, improve safety, and promote the underutilized AIFA, which was inaugurated in 2022 as a flagship infrastructure project. However, critics, including major U.S. cargo operators like FedEx, UPS, and DHL, contend that AIFA lacks the necessary facilities, such as adequate warehousing, customs processing capabilities, and efficient ground transportation links, making it an impractical alternative for time-sensitive shipments.

The U.S. government's response has been swift and multifaceted. According to the DOT's recent filing, the proposed restrictions would prevent Mexican passenger airlines from launching new routes or increasing frequencies to U.S. cities until the cargo ban is resolved. This could effectively freeze the expansion plans of carriers like Aeroméxico, Volaris, and VivaAerobus, which rely heavily on the lucrative U.S.-Mexico market. The transborder aviation sector is booming, with millions of passengers traveling annually between the two countries for business, leisure, and family visits. In 2023 alone, U.S.-Mexico air traffic surpassed pre-pandemic levels, underscoring the economic stakes involved.

This isn't the first time aviation safety and operational disputes have strained U.S.-Mexico relations. Back in May 2021, the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) downgraded Mexico's aviation safety rating from Category 1 to Category 2, citing deficiencies in the country's civil aviation authority, including inadequate inspector training, insufficient oversight of airlines, and staffing shortages. This downgrade already prohibits Mexican carriers from adding new U.S. services or altering existing ones, a restriction that remains in place. Mexico has been working diligently to address these issues, with officials claiming progress in audits and reforms. However, the cargo ban at AICM has added a new layer of complexity, prompting the U.S. to leverage its regulatory power to push for concessions.

U.S. officials have framed the proposed restrictions as a necessary measure to protect American interests. In a statement, a DOT spokesperson emphasized that the cargo ban "unilaterally disrupts established air cargo operations without adequate consultation or alternatives, violating the spirit of bilateral aviation agreements." The U.S.-Mexico bilateral air transport agreement, dating back to 2015, promotes open skies and fair competition, but it includes provisions for addressing disputes through negotiation. The DOT's move signals a willingness to escalate if talks fail, potentially leading to a formal complaint under the agreement's dispute resolution mechanisms.

From the Mexican side, the government defends the AICM cargo ban as a sovereign decision aimed at modernizing infrastructure. President López Obrador has repeatedly touted AIFA as a solution to AICM's woes, which include slot constraints, environmental concerns, and operational inefficiencies. Mexican transport officials argue that the relocation will ultimately benefit all stakeholders by creating a more balanced airport ecosystem. They point to investments in AIFA, such as expanded cargo terminals and improved highway connections, as evidence of commitment to the transition. However, industry analysts note that AIFA's remote location and initial teething problems have deterred adoption, with passenger traffic there remaining a fraction of AICM's volume.

The implications of the U.S. restrictions extend far beyond cargo logistics. For passenger airlines, the freeze on new routes could limit growth in high-demand markets like Los Angeles, Chicago, New York, and Houston, where Mexican carriers have been aggressively expanding. Aeroméxico, for instance, has partnerships with Delta Air Lines under an immunized joint venture that allows coordinated scheduling and revenue sharing. If restrictions broaden, this alliance could face scrutiny, potentially unraveling years of integration. Low-cost carriers like Volaris, which operate numerous cross-border flights, might see their business models challenged, leading to higher fares or reduced options for travelers.

Economically, the stakes are enormous. The U.S.-Mexico air cargo trade supports billions in commerce, from electronics and automotive parts to perishable goods like avocados and fresh produce. Disruptions could ripple through supply chains, increasing costs for businesses and consumers on both sides of the border. Tourism, a pillar of Mexico's economy, could also suffer if flight options dwindle, particularly for U.S. visitors heading to destinations like Cancún, Puerto Vallarta, and Mexico City. According to industry estimates, the bilateral aviation market generates over $20 billion annually in economic activity, employing thousands in related sectors.

Stakeholders have voiced mixed reactions. U.S. cargo giants have welcomed the DOT's stance, with a FedEx representative stating, "We appreciate the U.S. government's support in ensuring fair access to key markets. The abrupt ban at AICM threatens efficient global logistics." Conversely, Mexican airline executives have expressed frustration, arguing that the cargo issue should not spill over into passenger operations. An Aeroméxico spokesperson noted, "We urge dialogue to resolve this without penalizing passengers who rely on seamless connectivity."

Looking ahead, diplomatic channels remain open. Both countries are scheduled for high-level talks in the coming weeks, potentially under the auspices of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). Mexico has signaled willingness to provide transitional support for cargo operators at AIFA, such as expedited customs and infrastructure upgrades. Meanwhile, the U.S. has indicated that lifting the proposed restrictions hinges on Mexico reconsidering the AICM ban or offering viable alternatives.

This dispute highlights broader challenges in U.S.-Mexico relations, where economic interdependence often clashes with national priorities. Aviation, as a gateway for trade and mobility, serves as a barometer for bilateral ties. As negotiations unfold, the outcome will not only shape the future of air travel between the two nations but also test the resilience of their partnership in an era of increasing protectionism and infrastructure demands.

In the meantime, travelers and businesses are advised to monitor developments closely. For now, existing flights remain unaffected, but the specter of restrictions looms large, potentially reshaping the skies over North America. As one aviation expert put it, "This is more than a cargo spat—it's a battle over the rules of the air in one of the world's most integrated regions." With both sides digging in, a resolution may require compromise, but the path forward remains uncertain, underscoring the delicate balance of cooperation and competition in international aviation.

(Word count: 1,048)

Read the Full FreightWaves Article at:
[ https://www.yahoo.com/news/us-moves-restrict-mexican-airlines-190230340.html ]