N※N

US threatens Mexican airline flights over airline competition issues

US Escalates Aviation Dispute with Mexico, Threatens Ban on Cargo Flights Amid Safety and Trade Concerns

In a significant escalation of tensions between the United States and Mexico over aviation safety and bilateral trade agreements, the U.S. Department of Transportation has issued a stark warning to Mexican authorities. The threat centers on potentially prohibiting Mexican airlines from operating cargo flights into the United States, a move that could disrupt cross-border trade and logistics networks vital to both economies. This development stems from ongoing disputes regarding Mexico's aviation safety standards and recent legislative changes that the U.S. views as violations of long-standing international agreements.

The core issue traces back to 2021, when the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) downgraded Mexico's aviation safety rating from Category 1 to Category 2. This downgrade was not arbitrary; it reflected the FAA's assessment that Mexico's civil aviation authority, the Agencia Federal de Aviación Civil (AFAC), failed to meet the safety oversight standards set by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). Under Category 2 status, Mexican airlines are barred from expanding their services to the U.S., including adding new routes or increasing flight frequencies. However, existing operations have been allowed to continue under a grandfather clause, preserving the status quo for passenger and cargo flights that were already in place.

The latest flashpoint involves a new Mexican law that permits foreign airlines to conduct domestic cargo operations within Mexico—a practice known as cabotage. Cabotage typically restricts foreign carriers from transporting goods or passengers between two points within a single country, reserving such rights for domestic operators to protect local industries. Mexico's decision to open its domestic cargo market to foreign entities, including U.S.-based giants like FedEx and UPS, has been interpreted by Washington as a direct breach of the U.S.-Mexico bilateral aviation agreement. This agreement, which governs air services between the two nations, emphasizes reciprocity and fair competition.

In a formal letter addressed to Mexican officials, the U.S. Department of Transportation outlined its concerns explicitly. The letter warns that if Mexico proceeds with allowing U.S. cargo carriers to operate internal flights—such as from Mexico City to Monterrey—the U.S. will respond in kind by revoking permissions for Mexican airlines to fly cargo into American territory. This reciprocal action would effectively ground Mexican cargo operations to the U.S., impacting airlines like Aeroméxico Cargo, Volaris, and others that rely heavily on transborder routes for revenue. The DOT's position is that such a move by Mexico undermines the principles of equitable market access and could lead to an uneven playing field, where U.S. carriers gain advantages in Mexico without corresponding benefits for Mexican operators in the U.S.

To understand the broader context, it's essential to delve into the history of U.S.-Mexico aviation relations. The two countries have maintained a robust bilateral agreement since the 1960s, updated periodically to reflect evolving trade dynamics, especially after the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in 1994 and its successor, the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) in 2020. Aviation has been a cornerstone of this economic partnership, facilitating the movement of goods worth billions annually. Mexico is the U.S.'s largest trading partner, with cross-border cargo flights playing a pivotal role in sectors like automotive manufacturing, electronics, and perishable goods. For instance, Mexican exports to the U.S. include vast quantities of produce, machinery, and consumer products, many of which are transported via air to ensure timely delivery.

The FAA's 2021 downgrade was prompted by a series of audits revealing deficiencies in Mexico's oversight mechanisms. These included inadequate inspector training, insufficient regulatory enforcement, and lapses in accident investigation protocols. Mexican officials have repeatedly pledged to address these issues, working closely with ICAO and the FAA to regain Category 1 status. Progress has been made, with Mexico implementing reforms such as hiring more safety inspectors and updating certification processes. However, the U.S. has maintained that full compliance is necessary before any restoration of privileges.

Compounding the safety concerns are political and infrastructural elements. The opening of Mexico's new Felipe Ángeles International Airport (AIFA) in 2022, intended to alleviate congestion at Mexico City International Airport (AICM), has introduced new variables. Critics argue that AIFA's development and operations have not fully adhered to international standards, further straining relations. Additionally, Mexico's recent cabotage law appears tied to efforts to boost AIFA's cargo throughput, attracting foreign investment and operations to the underutilized facility. U.S. officials, however, see this as a strategic maneuver that circumvents bilateral norms, potentially allowing American carriers to dominate Mexican domestic routes at the expense of local competitors.

The potential ban on Mexican cargo flights carries profound economic implications. According to industry analysts, air cargo accounts for a significant portion of high-value trade between the two nations. In 2023 alone, the value of goods transported by air between the U.S. and Mexico exceeded $50 billion, underscoring the sector's importance. A prohibition could lead to supply chain disruptions, increased costs for shippers, and delays in critical industries. For example, the automotive sector, which relies on just-in-time deliveries of parts from Mexican maquiladoras to U.S. assembly plants, could face bottlenecks. Perishable exports like avocados and berries from Mexico might spoil en route if forced onto slower ground or sea transport alternatives.

Reactions from stakeholders have been swift and varied. Mexican airline executives have expressed alarm, arguing that the U.S. threat is disproportionate and could harm bilateral relations. A spokesperson for Aeroméxico emphasized the airline's commitment to safety and called for diplomatic negotiations to resolve the impasse. On the U.S. side, cargo operators like FedEx have remained cautious, noting that while access to Mexican domestic routes could expand their networks, they prioritize compliance with international agreements to avoid retaliatory measures.

Mexican government officials have downplayed the severity of the threat, asserting that the cabotage reforms are designed to modernize the aviation sector and stimulate economic growth. They point to similar liberalizations in other countries, such as within the European Union, as models for open skies policies. Nonetheless, Mexico has indicated a willingness to engage in talks with the U.S. to clarify the law's implementation and ensure it aligns with bilateral commitments.

This dispute also highlights broader geopolitical tensions. Aviation agreements often serve as proxies for larger trade negotiations, and with the USMCA up for review in 2026, aviation could become a bargaining chip. Environmental considerations add another layer; increased air cargo operations raise concerns about carbon emissions, prompting calls for sustainable practices amid global climate goals.

As negotiations unfold, the aviation industry watches closely. A resolution could involve Mexico providing assurances on cabotage restrictions or accelerating safety reforms to regain Category 1 status. Failure to do so might result in the U.S. following through on its threat, leading to a fragmented market and potential appeals to international bodies like the World Trade Organization.

In summary, the U.S. threat to ban Mexican cargo flights represents a critical juncture in North American aviation relations. It underscores the delicate balance between safety standards, economic interests, and reciprocal trade policies. Both nations stand to lose if the dispute escalates, but a collaborative approach could pave the way for strengthened ties and mutual benefits in the skies. As the situation develops, the focus remains on diplomacy to avert a full-blown aviation trade war that could ripple through the continent's economy. (Word count: 1,048)

Read the Full Reuters Article at:
[ https://www.yahoo.com/news/us-threatens-mexican-airline-flights-133112128.html ]