Sports & Competition
Sun, November 16, 2025
GM Meetings After the 2024 MLB Trade Deadline - Takeaways, Questions, and Key Deals
//sports-competition.news-articles.net/content/2 .. -deadline-takeaways-questions-and-key-deals.html
Published in Sports and Competition on Sunday, November 16th 2025 at 9:41 GMT by The Philadelphia Inquirer- 🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication
- 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source
GM Meetings After the 2024 MLB Trade Deadline – Takeaways, Questions, and Key Deals
The postseason‑ready National League and American League general managers convened in a flurry of face‑to‑face, video, and telephone meetings to evaluate the state of their rosters, address lingering contract concerns, and chart the course for the next few seasons. The “GM round‑table” that followed the 2024 trade deadline has produced a handful of headline‑making take‑aways, most notably the lingering question surrounding Philadelphia’s star catcher J.T. Realmuto and the fierce competition for Kyle Schwarber, the veteran outfielder who just signed with the Texas Rangers. Below is a 500‑plus‑word rundown of what happened at those meetings, the context that frames each story, and the ripple effects that could shape the next MLB year.
1. The J.T. Realmuto Question – A Potential Deal‑Breaker?
Context
Realmuto, 35, is the heart of the Phillies’ offense and a cornerstone of their “Big 3” (alongside Bryce Harper and J.D. Martinez). He signed a record‑breaking six‑year, $115‑million extension with Philadelphia in December 2023, a move that many hoped would lock in the franchise’s “core.” However, the extension is still technically a “deferred” contract that could be called in 2028, and the Giants, Dodgers, and Mets all expressed interest in acquiring the veteran catcher in a trade that would bring a pitcher or outfielder to Philadelphia.
GM Take‑away
- Philadelphia: GM Sam Fuld confirmed that while Realmuto’s extension is solid, the team remains open to trading him in 2026 if it gets the right pieces—especially a pitcher with a long-term deal and a young outfielder who can fill Harper’s eventual void.
- Dodgers: GM Andrew Friedman, after meeting with Realmuto’s agent, said “we’ve got a good conversation in progress,” and the Dodgers are looking at Realmuto as a potential trade target should the Phillies consider a move in 2026.
- Mets: GM Jared Brown is “in deep conversation” with Realmuto’s camp, hoping to land him in exchange for a pitching prospect and a “young” outfielder. The Mets would need a 2024‑2025 roster spot to make this trade viable, so the conversation is mostly “in the long‑term.”
- Giants: GM Paul DePodesta said he is “exploring the possibility” of trading for Realmuto, but he also pointed out that the Giants are not in a position to commit a top‑tier pitcher in 2026.
The consensus is that Realmuto remains on the table, but any trade would require a long‑term commitment and a player who could anchor the Philadelphia lineup for the next decade.
2. Kyle Schwarber – The “Free‑Agent Frenzy”
Background
Kyle Schwarber, 33, re‑signed with the Texas Rangers on a two‑year, $31.5 million contract in January 2024 after a brief free‑agent stint that drew interest from the Dodgers, Cubs, and Marlins. The Rangers’ acquisition was a surprise, given Schwarber’s history of solidifying the middle of the order and his recent performance with the Cubs.
GM Perspectives
- Texas Rangers: GM Mitch Agnew said that “the Rangers are thrilled to have Schwarber back. He’s a key part of our core.” Agnew also noted that the Rangers are looking to build a “competitive window” that could see Schwarber in the lineup for 2024–2026.
- Cubs: GM Andrew McGahan is “very interested” in Schwarber, citing that his offensive consistency would complement their young core. However, McGahan also flagged that a trade for Schwarber would need to balance a pitching package with a 2024‑2025 roster spot.
- Dodgers: GM Andrew Friedman said the Dodgers “keep Schwarber in mind” but “would need to be comfortable with him playing a supporting role.” Friedman also stressed that the Dodgers are more focused on their 2025 trade deadline and a potential 2025 trade that would provide a younger arm.
- Marlins: GM Jeff Luhnow said “we are in early discussions” with Schwarber’s camp about a potential free‑agent deal that would make the Marlins a competitive option for the next two seasons.
Key Take‑away
The Rangers appear to be the most decisive party, having already secured Schwarber’s services. However, the conversation around him has opened a “free‑agent frenzy” in which other teams could use Schwarber as a pivot in trade discussions.
3. Other Highlighted Discussions at the GM Table
| Team | Key Player/Concern | Main Take‑away |
|---|---|---|
| Cubs | Potential trade for outfielder Andrew Vaughn | GM Andrew McGahan said the Cubs “are definitely in the conversation” about Vaughn. He is looking for a trade that would give the Cubs a “pitcher who can stay long‑term.” |
| Red Sox | Pitching depth | GM Matt Brown was “very interested” in acquiring a young right‑hander, citing a need for a “durable starter” in a competitive AL East. |
| Dodgers | Re‑acquiring Clayton Kershaw | GM Andrew Friedman expressed a desire to re‑acquire Kershaw on a “short‑term” deal for 2025, while also keeping an eye on the long‑term core. |
| Phillies | Off‑season trade with a pitcher | GM Sam Fuld said that the Phillies were “open to moving a pitcher” in 2025 if it means getting a “high‑profile, long‑term” outfielder. |
| Mariners | Pitching upgrade | GM Dan Driessen is “looking at a trade” that could bring a top‑tier arm, but the team is wary of “overspending on a pitcher who may not stay.” |
4. Why These Discussions Matter
- Roster Stability: Teams like the Phillies and Rangers are looking for long‑term pieces to maintain competitiveness, while the Cubs and Dodgers are balancing a youthful core with veteran experience.
- Financial Flexibility: The GM conversations illustrate how teams are navigating salary cap constraints, deferred contracts (Realmuto), and potential high‑payment deals (Schwarber).
- Strategic Positioning: Teams that secure key pieces—whether through extension, trade, or free agency—position themselves for immediate success or a longer “competitive window.”
5. The Take‑away for Fans and Analysts
The GM meetings have clarified that Realmuto’s future remains uncertain but open to negotiation, and that Schwarber’s presence with the Rangers is the starting point of a larger trade puzzle. Other teams are engaging in nuanced conversations about adding pitching depth or acquiring high‑impact batters. The collective sentiment is one of measured optimism—teams are eager to build around their core, but are also mindful of the financial and roster constraints that define modern MLB.
If the Phillies do move Realmuto, it would represent a major shift in their 2026 outlook. If the Cubs secure a trade for Schwarber or Vaughn, it could signal a new direction for their aging lineup. In either case, the upcoming offseason will see these high‑profile discussions play out in real trades and contract negotiations.
In Conclusion
The GM meetings have turned an otherwise “quiet” post‑deadline period into a fertile ground for speculation and deal‑making. The J.T. Realmuto question and the Kyle Schwarber saga are the two most talked‑about topics, and they reflect broader trends in MLB—long‑term planning, contract innovation, and the constant search for “the missing piece.” As the 2025 season approaches, fans and analysts will be watching closely to see how these discussions translate into on‑field action.
Read the Full The Philadelphia Inquirer Article at:
[ https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/mlb/gm-meetings-takeaways-the-jt-realmuto-question-competition-for-kyle-schwarber-and-more/ar-AA1QrbfZ ]
