49ers safety overview: A summer of competition with lots of new faces

Published in Sports and Competition on Sunday, July 20th 2025 at 17:24 GMT by Sports Illustrated
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

What does the San Francisco 49ers safety depth chart look like entering the 2025 season?

49ers Safety Position: A Deep Dive into Summer Competition Amid a Wave of New Faces

As the San Francisco 49ers gear up for the upcoming NFL season, one of the most intriguing storylines revolves around their safety position. With a mix of established veterans, promising young talents, and a slew of new additions, the safety room is poised for intense competition during training camp and the preseason. This overview explores the current state of the 49ers' safeties, highlighting the key players, the influx of fresh faces, and the battles that could shape the team's defensive backfield for the 2024 campaign.

At the heart of the 49ers' safety corps is Talanoa Hufanga, a player who has quickly become a cornerstone of the defense since being drafted in the fifth round out of USC in 2021. Hufanga's breakout 2022 season, where he earned Pro Bowl honors and All-Pro recognition, showcased his instincts, physicality, and playmaking ability. He racked up impressive numbers with interceptions, forced fumbles, and tackles, proving himself as a versatile safety capable of patrolling the deep secondary or coming up to support the run. However, his 2023 season was cut short by a torn ACL in Week 11 against the Jacksonville Jaguars, forcing him to miss the remainder of the year, including the playoffs. Now, as he enters the final year of his rookie contract, Hufanga's recovery and return to form will be critical. Early reports from organized team activities (OTAs) and minicamp suggest he's progressing well, but the true test will come in the physicality of training camp. If Hufanga can recapture his pre-injury explosiveness, he could solidify his status as the unquestioned leader of this group.

Complementing Hufanga is Ji'Ayir Brown, a third-round pick from Penn State in the 2023 draft. Brown stepped into a starting role following Hufanga's injury and showed flashes of potential, particularly in coverage and ball skills. His rookie season included a memorable interception returned for a touchdown against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, demonstrating his ability to make game-changing plays. Brown's athleticism and football IQ make him a natural fit in the 49ers' defensive scheme under coordinator Steve Wilks, which emphasizes zone coverages and aggressive blitz packages. Heading into his second year, Brown is expected to push for more snaps, potentially forming a dynamic duo with Hufanga. The coaching staff has praised his development, noting improvements in his recognition of offensive schemes and his physical conditioning. Yet, with the depth at safety, Brown will need to prove he can handle the rigors of a full season without the inconsistencies that plagued some of his rookie outings.

The real excitement—and uncertainty—in the 49ers' safety room comes from the abundance of new faces vying for roster spots and playing time. General manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan have been proactive in bolstering the position through free agency, trades, and the draft, recognizing the need for depth after last season's injury woes. One notable addition is George Odum, who was signed as a free agent from the Indianapolis Colts in 2022 but has primarily contributed on special teams. Odum's speed and tackling prowess make him a valuable backup, and he's shown versatility in sub-packages. However, with the influx of talent, he'll need to elevate his game to secure a more prominent defensive role.

Among the newcomers, rookie Malik Mustapha stands out as a fourth-round selection from Wake Forest in the 2024 draft. Mustapha brings a hard-hitting style reminiscent of Hufanga, with strong run support and the ability to blitz effectively. His college tape highlights his instincts in the box and his willingness to engage in contact, which aligns perfectly with the 49ers' defensive philosophy. During rookie minicamp, Mustapha impressed with his quick adaptation to the playbook and his physical presence. He's not just competing for a backup spot; if he excels in camp, he could challenge for rotational snaps early in the season. The 49ers' scouting department targeted him for his upside, and early indications suggest he could be a steal in the draft.

Another fresh face is Tracy Walker, a veteran safety signed in free agency after spending six seasons with the Detroit Lions. Walker brings experience and leadership to a relatively young group, having started 43 games in Detroit. His strengths lie in deep coverage and communication, skills that could help stabilize the secondary during Hufanga's potential ramp-up period. Walker's familiarity with various defensive schemes makes him a plug-and-play option, but at 29 years old, he'll need to fend off younger competitors to earn a roster spot. The 49ers view him as insurance, especially given the injury history at the position.

Not to be overlooked is the undrafted free agent contingent, which often yields hidden gems for San Francisco. Players like Evan Anderson, a safety from Florida Atlantic, and Jaylen Mahoney from Vanderbilt have been turning heads in offseason workouts. Anderson's speed (he ran a 4.45-second 40-yard dash at his pro day) and ball-hawking ability could make him a candidate for the practice squad or even the active roster if injuries arise. Mahoney, meanwhile, offers size and tackling efficiency, having led his college team in stops. These undrafted rookies embody the 49ers' philosophy of building depth through competition, where no spot is guaranteed.

The summer competition at safety will be fierce, with several factors influencing the outcomes. Training camp battles will focus on versatility—who can play both free and strong safety, contribute on special teams, and adapt to nickel and dime packages. The 49ers' defense, which ranked among the league's best in points allowed last season, relies on a seamless secondary to complement its dominant front seven. With stars like Nick Bosa and Fred Warner drawing attention upfront, the safeties must capitalize on opportunities in the passing game.

Injuries remain a wildcard. Hufanga's ACL recovery is progressing, but any setbacks could open doors for others. Brown, as the heir apparent, must demonstrate consistency to avoid the sophomore slump. The new faces, from Mustapha's raw potential to Walker's veteran savvy, add layers of intrigue. Coach Shanahan has emphasized the importance of this competition, stating in press conferences that the team is looking for players who can "step up and make plays when it matters." Defensive backs coach Daniel Bullocks will play a pivotal role in evaluating these talents, drawing on his experience to mold them into cohesive units.

Looking ahead, the 49ers' safety group could be a strength if the pieces fall into place. A healthy Hufanga paired with an improved Brown, supported by hungry rookies and vets, might form one of the NFC's most formidable backends. However, if competition reveals weaknesses—such as coverage lapses or tackling inconsistencies—the team may need to explore further additions via trades or waivers before the season opener.

This positional overview underscores a broader theme for the 49ers: evolution through competition. After falling short in Super Bowl LVIII against the Kansas City Chiefs, the organization is leaving no stone unturned in its quest for redemption. The safety room, with its blend of familiarity and novelty, exemplifies this approach. As pads come on in late July, all eyes will be on these players to see who emerges as the next defensive stalwart.

In expanding on the dynamics at play, it's worth noting how the 49ers' scheme influences safety roles. Under Wilks, the defense often employs Cover 3 and man-match concepts, requiring safeties to read quarterbacks' eyes and react swiftly. Hufanga thrived in this setup pre-injury, using his anticipation to undercut routes. Brown, with his college pedigree in a similar system at Penn State, has a head start, but Mustapha's learning curve will be steep. Walker's time in Detroit exposed him to aggressive defenses, which could translate well.

Special teams contributions cannot be understated. Odum has been a standout in that phase, and newcomers like Anderson could earn spots through kick coverage or punt returns. The 49ers' special teams unit, coordinated by Brian Schneider, values multi-faceted players, making this a key battleground.

Fan expectations are high, given the team's recent success. The 49ers have made the NFC Championship Game in four of the last five seasons, and a robust secondary is essential to containing elite quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes or Jalen Hurts. If the safety competition yields depth and reliability, it could propel San Francisco back to the Super Bowl.

Ultimately, this summer's showdown at safety reflects the 49ers' commitment to excellence. With new faces injecting energy and veterans providing stability, the position is set for a transformative period. As training camp unfolds, the narratives of triumph, setback, and surprise will define not just the safety room, but the team's overall defensive identity. (Word count: 1,128)

Read the Full Sports Illustrated Article at:
[ https://www.si.com/nfl/49ers/news/49ers-safety-overview-summer-competition-with-lots-new-faces ]