N※N

Cubs-Yankees Trade Rumors: Hoerner as Shortstop Solution?

  //sports-competition.news-articles.net/content/2 .. -trade-rumors-hoerner-as-shortstop-solution.html
  Published in Sports and Competition on Friday, February 20th 2026 at 0:46 GMT by Sporting News
      Locales: Illinois, New York, UNITED STATES

Cubs-Yankees Trade Rumors Heat Up: Nico Hoerner as the Key to Solving a Shortstop Dilemma?

Friday, February 20th, 2026 - As Spring Training progresses, the New York Yankees are increasingly feeling the pressure to address their ongoing issues at shortstop. Despite signing Isiah Kiner-Falefa, his performance has remained underwhelming, and the hoped-for breakthrough from Oswald Peraza hasn't materialized. This has intensified their search for a reliable, consistent presence at a critical position. Meanwhile, in Chicago, the Cubs are evaluating their roster and considering options that might offer greater flexibility and allow their burgeoning young talent to gain Major League experience. This convergence of needs has led to speculation surrounding Chicago Cubs shortstop Nico Hoerner and a potential trade to the Bronx.

Hoerner, a fixture at shortstop for the Cubs since his debut in 2020, has been a consistently solid defensive player. However, a discernible dip in offensive production has sparked debate about his long-term fit with the North Siders. While he showcased promise with a .255 batting average and .732 OPS in 2022, his numbers slipped to a .637 OPS in 2023, raising questions about his ability to provide the offensive punch the Cubs desire. The emergence of several highly-touted infield prospects within the Cubs organization, including Nicolet, Marcel Marcondes, and Owen Caissie, further complicates the situation, creating a potential surplus of middle infield talent.

Why Hoerner Appeals to the Yankees

The Yankees' primary need is stability and quality at shortstop. Hoerner offers both. His defensive prowess is well-documented, consistently ranking him among the league's better fielding shortstops. Beyond defense, Hoerner isn't an offensive liability. While his 2023 season wasn't stellar, his previous performance demonstrates the potential for a respectable batting average and on-base percentage. Crucially, Hoerner is under team control for three more seasons at a relatively affordable salary, a significant benefit for the Yankees who are mindful of staying under the luxury tax threshold. Acquiring Hoerner would provide a proven, cost-effective solution at shortstop, allowing the Yankees to allocate resources to other areas of need.

The Cubs' Perspective: Embracing Youth and Flexibility

For the Cubs, trading Hoerner isn't about getting rid of a bad player; it's about strategically optimizing their roster for both the present and the future. The offensive decline, coupled with the depth of young infield talent, makes Hoerner a potentially valuable trade asset. Moving Hoerner would open up playing time for prospects like Nicolet, allowing the Cubs' front office to assess their potential at the Major League level. Furthermore, a trade could net the Cubs players who better fit their long-term vision or address other positional needs. This isn't about a rebuild; it's about a calculated move to maximize the team's competitive window.

Possible Trade Scenarios

Several trade packages have been floated, with varying degrees of complexity:

• Simple Swap: Yankees receive Nico Hoerner; Cubs receive Oswald Peraza. This is the most straightforward scenario, offering the Yankees a proven shortstop and the Cubs a young player with upside, although Peraza hasn't yet established himself as an everyday player.

• Expanding the Package: Yankees receive Nico Hoerner and Daniel Palencia; Cubs receive Oswald Peraza and Everson Pereira. This deal provides both teams with additional assets. Palencia is a promising pitching prospect, while Pereira offers outfield depth and potential offensive upside for the Cubs.

• Focus on Prospect Potential: Yankees receive Nico Hoerner; Cubs receive Spencer Lipps. This trade prioritizes giving the Cubs a chance to develop Lipps, a player who could provide immediate depth or become a future starter.

Beyond Hoerner: Other Potential Moves for Both Teams The Cubs aren't limited to moving just Hoerner. Ian Happ, a pending free agent after the 2026 season, could also be a valuable trade chip. Seiya Suzuki, a young outfielder with considerable potential, could attract significant interest, while Cody Bellinger, also a free agent after this season, is projected to command a substantial contract, making a trade more likely than a re-signing.

The Yankees, too, have potential trade candidates. Veterans like Josh Donaldson, Frankie Montas, and Lou Trivino could be moved to free up roster space and acquire younger talent. However, their value is limited due to their age and/or recent performance.

Ultimately, the success of any trade hinges on both teams finding a package that addresses their respective needs and aligns with their long-term goals. The next few weeks leading up to the trade deadline will be crucial in determining whether Nico Hoerner will be exchanging a Cubs uniform for pinstripes.