Saints QB Competition Update Where Things Stand

Published in Sports and Competition on Wednesday, July 23rd 2025 at 20:44 GMT by Sports Illustrated
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

Training camp is here and with it also is the New Orleans Saints'' quarterback competition. This has been the talking point of the offseason and now Tyler Shough

Saints QB Competition Heats Up: Latest Updates and Where Things Stand

In the sweltering heat of New Orleans Saints training camp, the quarterback room has become a focal point of intrigue and speculation. As the team gears up for the upcoming NFL season, the battle for positions behind starter Derek Carr is intensifying, with young guns Spencer Rattler and Jake Haener vying for the backup role. This update dives deep into the current state of affairs, drawing from recent practices, preseason performances, and insights from coaches and players. While Carr remains firmly entrenched as the QB1, the competition among the reserves is not just about depth—it's about the future of the franchise in a post-Drew Brees era.

Let's start with the incumbent starter, Derek Carr. Acquired from the Las Vegas Raiders in a high-profile move last offseason, Carr has been the unquestioned leader of the Saints' offense. His experience and poise have been evident throughout camp. Head coach Dennis Allen has repeatedly praised Carr's command of the new offensive scheme under coordinator Klint Kubiak. "Derek's been sharp," Allen noted in a recent press conference. "He's making the right reads, protecting the ball, and elevating the guys around him." Carr's stats from last season—3,878 passing yards, 25 touchdowns, and just eight interceptions—underscore his reliability. But beyond the numbers, it's his leadership that's shining through. Teammates like wide receiver Chris Olave have spoken about Carr's ability to build chemistry, often staying late after practice to work on timing routes. In preseason games, Carr has looked comfortable, completing short drives with precision and showing improved pocket presence, a key area of focus after some injury concerns in the past.

However, the real drama unfolds in the race for the No. 2 spot. Enter Spencer Rattler, the fifth-round draft pick out of South Carolina who has turned heads with his arm talent and moxie. Rattler, once a highly touted prospect whose college career had its ups and downs, arrived in New Orleans with something to prove. Early in camp, he struggled with consistency, overthrowing receivers and making rookie mistakes under pressure. But as the weeks progressed, Rattler has shown marked improvement. In the Saints' first preseason game against the Arizona Cardinals, he orchestrated a touchdown drive in the second half, displaying his trademark velocity on deep balls. "Spencer's got that gunslinger mentality," said offensive coordinator Kubiak. "He's learning the playbook quickly and not afraid to take risks." Rattler's ability to extend plays with his mobility has been a pleasant surprise, reminiscent of a young Baker Mayfield. Fans and analysts alike are buzzing about his potential, especially given the Saints' history of developing quarterbacks. If Rattler continues to progress, he could push for meaningful snaps if Carr faces any setbacks.

On the other side of the competition is Jake Haener, the second-year quarterback from Fresno State who spent much of his rookie season on the sidelines. Haener's journey has been anything but straightforward. A suspension for a banned substance violation sidelined him early last year, but he's returned with a vengeance. Known for his accuracy and quick release, Haener has been the model of consistency in camp. During 7-on-7 drills, he's completed over 80% of his passes, according to team observers, often threading needles in tight coverage. In the preseason opener, Haener led a field-goal drive, showcasing his poise in managing the huddle. "Jake's a student of the game," Allen commented. "He's put in the work to understand our system inside and out." What sets Haener apart is his football IQ; he's been praised for his pre-snap reads and ability to audible effectively. However, questions linger about his arm strength on longer throws, which could limit his ceiling compared to Rattler's raw talent.

The competition between Rattler and Haener isn't just a two-man race—it's a microcosm of the Saints' broader quarterback strategy. With Carr turning 33 this season, the team is clearly investing in youth to build a succession plan. Practice reps have been split evenly, with both backups getting opportunities with the first-team offense. This approach has fostered a healthy rivalry, as evidenced by the mutual respect expressed in interviews. Rattler has called Haener "a great competitor who's pushing me every day," while Haener echoed the sentiment, saying, "Spencer's got elite tools; it's making us both better." Coaches have emphasized that the decision will come down to performance in live situations, particularly in the remaining preseason games. The upcoming matchup against the San Francisco 49ers will be crucial, as it pits the backups against a stout defense, testing their mettle under fire.

Beyond the on-field action, there are strategic implications for the Saints' season outlook. The NFC South remains winnable, with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers as the primary competition. A reliable backup quarterback could be the difference in a tight division race, especially if injuries arise—a harsh reality in the NFL. Last season, the Saints finished 9-8, missing the playoffs partly due to offensive inconsistencies. Strengthening the QB depth addresses that vulnerability. Moreover, the development of Rattler and Haener could provide trade value down the line or serve as insurance policies. Analysts have drawn parallels to successful QB rooms like those in Green Bay during the Aaron Rodgers era, where backups like Jordan Love were groomed patiently.

Fan reactions have been mixed but enthusiastic. Social media is abuzz with debates over who should win the backup job. Some supporters favor Rattler's upside, citing his college highlights and potential for big plays. Others lean toward Haener's reliability, arguing that in a conservative offense, steadiness trumps flash. Local podcasts and forums are dissecting every throw, with some even speculating about a potential three-QB roster to keep both young talents. The Saints' front office, led by general manager Mickey Loomis, has a history of bold moves at the position—think back to the Brees signing or the Taysom Hill experiments. This competition feels like the next chapter in that legacy.

As camp winds down, the coaching staff faces tough decisions. Allen has indicated that no final call will be made until after the final preseason game, allowing for maximum evaluation. "We're not rushing this," he said. "Both guys have shown they can play at this level." Whichever way it shakes out, the Saints appear to have depth that many teams envy. Rattler's raw athleticism could make him the heir apparent, while Haener's polish might earn him the immediate nod. For now, the competition is wide open, adding an extra layer of excitement to what promises to be a pivotal season for New Orleans.

Looking ahead, the integration of these quarterbacks into Kubiak's offense will be key. The scheme, influenced by the Shanahan tree, emphasizes play-action and misdirection, which plays to Carr's strengths but challenges the backups to adapt quickly. Rattler has spoken about studying film of successful implementations, like those in San Francisco, to refine his footwork. Haener, meanwhile, has focused on building rapport with the second-string receivers, ensuring smooth execution. Injuries to other positions, such as the offensive line, could indirectly impact the QB battle by forcing more improvised plays.

In the broader NFL landscape, this Saints situation mirrors trends across the league. Teams are increasingly prioritizing quarterback development amid a talent-rich draft class. Rattler, once projected as a first-rounder, represents the value found in later rounds, much like Brock Purdy's rise with the 49ers. For the Saints, nurturing this talent could pay dividends, potentially turning a good team into a contender.

As the preseason progresses, all eyes will remain on this quarterback trio. Carr provides stability, while Rattler and Haener inject youthful energy. The outcome of this competition could shape not just the depth chart but the trajectory of the franchise. Saints fans, ever passionate, are in for a thrilling ride as the pieces fall into place. Whether it's Rattler's cannon arm or Haener's cerebral approach that prevails, one thing is certain: the future at quarterback in New Orleans looks brighter than it has in years.

(Word count: 1,128)

Read the Full Sports Illustrated Article at:
[ https://www.si.com/nfl/saints/saints-news/saints-qb-competition-update-where-things-stand-pat3 ]