• Fri, August 8, 2025
  • Sat, August 9, 2025

Fantasy Baseball Bullpen Breakdown: Your Guide to MLB Closers

Our updated reliever depth chart displays the closer hierarchy for each team, as well as the fatigue factor in each MLB bullpen.

Fantasy Baseball Closer Organizational Chart: Bullpen Breakdowns for All 30 MLB Teams


In the world of fantasy baseball, navigating the volatile landscape of MLB bullpens is crucial for success, especially when chasing saves. This organizational chart provides a detailed look at each team's closer situation, highlighting the primary closer, key setup men, potential challengers, and any notable injuries or uncertainties. Bullpens can shift rapidly due to performance slumps, trades, or managerial decisions, so fantasy managers should monitor usage patterns closely. We'll break it down by division, starting with the American League East.

American League East


Baltimore Orioles: Craig Kimbrel remains the entrenched closer, bringing his veteran experience and high-strikeout stuff to the role. Despite occasional control issues, he's locked in with a strong track record. Felix Bautista, recovering from Tommy John surgery, is sidelined until at least mid-season, leaving Yennier Cano as the primary setup man and next in line. Dillon Tate provides depth, but Kimbrel's job is secure for now.

Boston Red Sox: Kenley Jansen holds the ninth-inning reins, leveraging his cutter and command to rack up saves. However, his age and occasional velocity dips make him a slight risk. Chris Martin and Justin Slaten form a solid bridge, with Slaten emerging as a potential heir apparent if Jansen falters. The Red Sox's bullpen depth is improving, but Jansen's experience keeps him atop the chart.

New York Yankees: Clay Holmes has solidified his status as the closer, mixing a nasty sinker with groundball tendencies. His consistency has been key in high-leverage spots. Luke Weaver and Tommy Kahnle handle setup duties, but injuries have thinned the ranks. If Holmes struggles, Weaver could step up, though the Yankees prefer stability.

Tampa Bay Rays: Pete Fairbanks is the go-to guy when healthy, boasting a devastating fastball-slider combo. Arm issues have plagued him, opening the door for Jason Adam as a reliable alternative. Colin Poche adds lefty depth, making this a committee-prone situation if Fairbanks misses time.

Toronto Blue Jays: Jordan Romano anchors the bullpen with his high-90s heat and sharp slider. Despite a recent elbow scare, he's back and dominating. Yimi Garcia and Erik Swanson provide setup support, with Garcia's versatility making him a sneaky stash for saves.

American League Central


Chicago White Sox: Michael Kopech has transitioned to the closer role, using his triple-digit fastball to overpower hitters. It's a work in progress, but his upside is immense. John Brebbia and Steven Wilson set up, though the team's overall struggles limit save opportunities.

Cleveland Guardians: Emmanuel Clase is arguably the best closer in baseball, with his cutter generating weak contact and elite velocity. He's a fantasy cornerstone. James Karinchak and Scott Barlow bolster the pen, but Clase's job is ironclad.

Detroit Tigers: Jason Foley has emerged as the primary closer, relying on grounders and command. Alex Lange lurks as a high-upside option if Foley slips. The Tigers' bullpen is young and volatile, so monitor closely.

Kansas City Royals: James McArthur has taken over closing duties, mixing pitches effectively in short bursts. Will Smith and Chris Stratton provide veteran presence, but McArthur's recent success has him locked in.

Minnesota Twins: Jhoan Duran is the flame-throwing closer, with his splinker and curveball baffling hitters. Griffin Jax and Brock Stewart set up, forming one of the AL's deeper units. Duran's health is key after past arm concerns.

American League West


Houston Astros: Josh Hader, the prized free-agent signing, dominates as closer with his wipeout slider. Ryan Pressly shifts to setup, adding depth alongside Bryan Abreu. This bullpen is stacked, making Hader a top-tier fantasy asset.

Los Angeles Angels: Carlos Estevez holds the role, but his command wavers. Robert Stephenson's injury hurts depth, with Luis Garcia and Matt Moore as alternatives. It's a shaky situation ripe for change.

Oakland Athletics: Mason Miller has burst onto the scene as closer, touching 100+ mph with nasty stuff. Lucas Erceg sets up, but Miller's electric arm makes him a fantasy darling despite the team's woes.

Seattle Mariners: Andres Munoz is the reliable closer, featuring a devastating slider. Matt Brash, out with injury, leaves Gabe Speier and Ryne Stanek to bridge. Munoz's consistency shines in a pitcher-friendly park.

Texas Rangers: Jose Leclerc has reclaimed the ninth, but inconsistency looms. David Robertson and Kirby Yates provide veteran options, potentially forming a committee if Leclerc falters.

National League East


Atlanta Braves: Raisel Iglesias is the steady closer, with pinpoint control and a nasty changeup. A.J. Minter and Joe Jimenez set up, making this one of the NL's most reliable pens.

Miami Marlins: Tanner Scott anchors the back end with his high-velocity fastball. A.J. Puk and Anthony Bender provide support, though the Marlins' rebuild limits saves.

New York Mets: Edwin Diaz is back as the elite closer, his slider as filthy as ever post-injury. Adam Ottavino and Brooks Raley bridge, but Diaz's return stabilizes everything.

Philadelphia Phillies: Jose Alvarado has the closer gig, mixing heat with a cutter. Jeff Hoffman and Orion Kerkering add depth in a deep unit.

Washington Nationals: Kyle Finnegan is the primary saver, with Hunter Harvey as a strong setup man. The Nats' pen is improving but still volatile.

National League Central


Chicago Cubs: Hector Neris has stepped up as closer, bringing experience to a young team. Adbert Alzolay's struggles opened the door, with Mark Leiter Jr. in setup.

Cincinnati Reds: Alexis Diaz holds the role, echoing his brother's prowess. Lucas Sims and Fernando Cruz support in a promising pen.

Milwaukee Brewers: Trevor Megill has filled in admirably with Devin Williams sidelined by back issues. Abner Uribe looms as a future star.

Pittsburgh Pirates: David Bednar is the reliable closer, with Aroldis Chapman adding firepower in setup.

St. Louis Cardinals: Ryan Helsley dominates with triple-digit heat. Andrew Kittredge sets up in a solid unit.

National League West


Arizona Diamondbacks: Paul Sewald is the closer when healthy, but injuries have tested depth. Kevin Ginkel steps up as needed.

Colorado Rockies: Justin Lawrence leads a committee, with Tyler Kinley involved. Coors Field hurts fantasy value.

Los Angeles Dodgers: Evan Phillips anchors, with Brusdar Graterol and Joe Kelly in support.

San Diego Padres: Robert Suarez has seized the role, outpitching Yuki Matsui.

San Francisco Giants: Camilo Doval's electric stuff makes him the closer, with Tyler Rogers setting up.

This chart underscores the fluidity of bullpen roles—fantasy managers should prioritize handcuffs like setup men with closer upside. Factors like team performance, injuries, and managerial preferences can alter hierarchies overnight. For instance, in committees like the Angels or Rockies, streaming options might yield short-term saves, while elite arms like Clase or Hader offer set-it-and-forget-it reliability. Staying ahead requires tracking recent outings, pitch counts, and beat writer insights. As the season progresses, expect trades at the deadline to shake things up further, potentially elevating prospects or shifting veterans into new roles. This breakdown serves as a snapshot; always cross-reference with the latest news for optimal roster decisions. (Word count: 928)

Read the Full ESPN Article at:
https://www.espn.com/fantasy/baseball/flb/story?page=REcloserorgchart