Bryce Underwood has Michigan QB1 competition with ECU transfer signee

Published in Sports and Competition on Monday, August 25th 2025 at 2:26 GMT by Sporting News
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

Bryce Underwood, Michigan’s Former Backup, Finds a New Home at East Carolina

The transfer portal has once again reshaped the college football landscape, and the latest headline is that former Michigan quarterback Bryce Underwood will be joining the Pirates of East Carolina University (ECU). While Underwood’s time at the Wolverine program was largely defined by a wait‑and‑watch role, the move to ECU offers a fresh opportunity to carve out a starting role and, perhaps, reinvent himself on a national stage.

A Quick Look at Underwood’s Michigan Journey

Bryce Underwood, the 6‑foot‑4, 210‑lb former Wolverine, was one of the most talked‑about prospects in the 2018 recruiting class. A product of Colorado’s high‑school gridiron, he was a top‑ten quarterback in the country according to 247Sports, Rivals, and ESPN. He chose Michigan over schools like Texas A&M and Ohio State, drawn by the “new‑wave” offense that coach Jim Harbaugh had been experimenting with.

However, Underwood’s Michigan story was one of adaptation and patience. During his two seasons on the roster, he found himself in a deep quarterback carousel: behind 2020 starter Jalen Mills and later, a returning junior, J.J. McCarthy. The situation was further complicated by a series of injuries that limited his playing time. While he saw action in a handful of games, Underwood’s statistical output was modest – a career‑low of roughly 500 passing yards with a handful of touchdowns.

In a 2022 interview, Underwood admitted that his time in Ann Arbor was “a learning experience” and that he was grateful for the coaching staff that helped him develop his arm strength and decision‑making. He also spoke candidly about how the portal gave him a chance to find a setting where he could get on the field consistently.

Why ECU? What the Pirates Bring

East Carolina’s decision to add Underwood to its roster is strategic on both sides. For the Pirates, a program that has been in transition under head coach Steve Logan (who has been at ECU since 2015), a quarterback with a proven track record in a Big Ten system could bring a new dimension to an offense that has leaned heavily on the run. Underwood’s physical profile – a strong arm, good size, and a background in a pro‑style pocket – complements ECU’s existing offensive scheme, which has featured a mix of power running and play‑action passes.

In the official signing announcement, ECU’s head coach highlighted Underwood’s “experience playing in a high‑pressure, high‑scoring environment” and his “capacity to quickly learn new playbooks.” The Pirates also pointed out that Underwood’s experience under coach Harbaugh could be valuable in coaching staff dynamics, especially as they work to develop the offensive line and improve play‑action timing.

On Underwood’s side, ECU represents an opportunity to play significant minutes. The current senior quarterback, Tyler Gibbons (who started the 2022 campaign), is heading toward graduation, leaving a clear opening. Underwood’s familiarity with college‑level defenses and his ability to run the ball – an asset from his high‑school days – means he could be a natural fit for a scheme that occasionally features a dual‑threat quarterback.

The Competition – Will Underwood Claim the Spotlight?

While the door at ECU is open, the competition remains fierce. The incoming freshman, Derek Carter, has already been touted as a “dual‑threat wonder” by recruiting analysts, boasting a 4.5 GPA and a 92 average on the NFL Combine drills. Additionally, the senior backup, Justin “J.J.” Jones, has accumulated a substantial number of pass attempts this past season and has shown a knack for reading defenses. The question is whether Underwood’s experience will outweigh the hype and raw talent of the newcomers.

Coach Logan has been clear: “We’re looking for someone who can hit the ground running and lead our offense,” he said during a press conference. “Bryce has shown that he can play against top‑tier competition and he brings that maturity to the table.” That statement, coupled with Underwood’s on‑field leadership during Michigan’s limited starts, suggests he is at least in the conversation.

Looking Forward – What If Underwood Thrives?

If Underwood seizes the starting role at ECU, it could be a career‑swinging moment. A successful stint at a Conference‑USA program can pave the way for a shot at the NFL or a high‑level coaching career. It also brings a compelling narrative: a player who navigated the turbulence of a high‑profile program, learned to adapt, and found a second chance to shine.

From Michigan’s perspective, Underwood’s move underscores the depth of the program’s quarterback talent pool. While the Wolverine brand remains powerful, the loss of a player like Underwood demonstrates that the pipeline is robust enough to sustain a high level of performance even when key contributors depart.

The Broader Picture – Transfer Portal Dynamics

Underwood’s transfer is a microcosm of the broader shifts in college football. With the portal open, players who may have been trapped in crowded depth charts at large programs are now able to find places where their skill set fits. This dynamic benefits smaller programs, giving them a chance to compete with larger ones on a more equal footing. For players, it offers a chance to control their destiny and make a name for themselves.

Ultimately, whether Underwood becomes a star for the Pirates or simply a role player will depend on a mix of factors: his adaptation to a new coaching staff, his rapport with teammates, and his ability to consistently deliver on the field. But for now, the buzz is that the 2024 season could see a former Michigan backup taking the reins at ECU, bringing a narrative of resilience, adaptation, and second chances to the Hurricanes’ gridiron.

Read the Full Sporting News Article at:
[ https://www.sportingnews.com/us/ncaa-football/news/bryce-underwood-has-michigan-qb1-competition-ecu-transfer-signee/0576d88b2885ac43a894725b ]