Browns QB Competition Sparks Surprising Advice From Former Pro

Published in Sports and Competition on Sunday, July 27th 2025 at 16:26 GMT by Newsweek
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

The Cleveland Browns have received major quarterback advice from a former NFL signal caller.

Browns QB Competition Ignites Debate: Former Pro Delivers Surprising Advice

In the ever-competitive landscape of the NFL, quarterback battles often define a team's trajectory, and the Cleveland Browns find themselves at the center of one such intriguing saga this offseason. With Deshaun Watson entrenched as the presumed starter but facing lingering questions about his performance and health, the emergence of Jameis Winston as a viable challenger has sparked widespread discussion. Adding fuel to the fire is some unexpected counsel from a former NFL quarterback who knows a thing or two about overcoming odds and seizing opportunities. This advice, coming from none other than Hall of Famer Kurt Warner, challenges conventional wisdom and urges the Browns to prioritize merit over reputation in their decision-making process.

To fully appreciate the context of this quarterback competition, it's essential to delve into the backgrounds of the key players involved. Deshaun Watson, once hailed as one of the league's brightest young stars during his tenure with the Houston Texans, arrived in Cleveland via a blockbuster trade in 2022. The Browns committed a staggering $230 million fully guaranteed contract to him, signaling their belief in his potential to lead them to Super Bowl glory. Watson's resume is impressive: multiple Pro Bowl selections, leading the league in passing yards in 2020, and a reputation for dynamic playmaking. However, his time in Cleveland has been marred by controversy and setbacks. Off-field legal issues stemming from allegations of sexual misconduct led to an 11-game suspension in 2022, disrupting his integration with the team. On the field, injuries have further hampered his progress. A shoulder injury limited him to just six starts last season, where he threw for 1,115 yards, seven touchdowns, and four interceptions—numbers that fell short of expectations for a quarterback of his caliber and contract.

Enter Jameis Winston, the former No. 1 overall pick by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2015. Winston's career has been a rollercoaster of highs and lows. Known for his cannon arm and fearless gunslinger mentality, he led the league in passing yards in 2019 with over 5,000 yards but also infamously threw 30 interceptions that same year—a dubious record that underscored his turnover-prone tendencies. After stints with the New Orleans Saints, where he served primarily as a backup and occasional starter, Winston signed with the Browns this offseason to provide depth behind Watson. At 30 years old, Winston brings experience, charisma, and a renewed focus on decision-making, having learned under quarterbacks like Drew Brees. In limited action last season with the Saints, he showed flashes of efficiency, completing 53.2% of his passes for 264 yards, two touchdowns, and three interceptions in seven games. His enthusiasm and leadership have already made waves in Cleveland's training camp, where reports indicate he's pushing Watson hard and impressing coaches with his preparation and arm talent.

The competition between Watson and Winston has intensified during the Browns' organized team activities (OTAs) and minicamp, with both quarterbacks receiving reps with the first-team offense. Head coach Kevin Stefanski has publicly downplayed any notion of a true battle, reiterating that Watson is the starter when healthy. However, the Browns' front office and coaching staff are acutely aware of the team's playoff aspirations. Cleveland boasts a formidable defense led by stars like Myles Garrett and a solid running game anchored by Nick Chubb's anticipated return from injury. The missing piece has often been consistent quarterback play, as evidenced by last season's carousel that saw Joe Flacco lead them to the playoffs after Watson's injury. With the AFC North division stacked with talents like Lamar Jackson in Baltimore, Joe Burrow in Cincinnati, and Russell Wilson in Pittsburgh, the Browns cannot afford mediocrity at the most critical position.

This is where Kurt Warner's surprising advice enters the fray. Warner, a two-time NFL MVP and Super Bowl champion with the St. Louis Rams (now Los Angeles Rams) and Arizona Cardinals, recently shared his thoughts on the Browns' situation during an appearance on a sports podcast. Warner's own career is a testament to perseverance and opportunity: undrafted out of college, he toiled in arena football and as a grocery store clerk before bursting onto the scene in 1999, leading the Rams to a Super Bowl victory in his first season as a starter. His journey from obscurity to stardom gives him unique credibility when discussing quarterback competitions.

Warner's counsel to the Browns is straightforward yet provocative: if Jameis Winston outperforms Deshaun Watson in training camp and preseason games, the team should seriously consider starting Winston. "You've got to go with the hot hand," Warner emphasized. "It doesn't matter what you paid or what the expectations are—football is about performance right now. If Winston is making better decisions, protecting the ball, and moving the offense, you owe it to the team to give him the nod." This advice surprises many because it directly challenges the sunk-cost fallacy that often plagues NFL teams. The Browns' massive investment in Watson could make benching him a public relations nightmare and a financial headache, given the contract's structure. Yet Warner argues that clinging to a high-profile name at the expense of on-field results is a recipe for failure. He drew parallels to his own experience, noting how the Rams' decision to stick with him over more established options paid dividends.

Expanding on this, Warner highlighted specific attributes that could tip the scales in Winston's favor. He praised Winston's ability to stretch the field vertically, a skill that complements the Browns' receiving corps, including Amari Cooper and the newly acquired Jerry Jeudy. Warner cautioned, however, that Winston must curb his interception issues, a flaw that has defined much of his career. For Watson, Warner suggested focusing on regaining rhythm and confidence post-injury, emphasizing the importance of footwork and quick releases to avoid the sacks that plagued him last year (he was sacked 20 times in six games). Warner's overarching message is one of meritocracy: "In the NFL, every snap is an audition. The Browns have a talented roster; they need the quarterback who gives them the best chance to win, period."

The implications of Warner's advice extend beyond the Browns' immediate quarterback dilemma. It raises broader questions about how teams evaluate and manage high-stakes positions. In an era where quarterback contracts routinely exceed $200 million, the pressure to justify those investments can lead to stubborn adherence to underperforming players. Warner's perspective encourages a more fluid approach, where competition breeds excellence and decisions are data-driven rather than ego-driven. For the Browns, embracing this mindset could be transformative. If Watson rebounds and reclaims his elite form, the competition will have served as a motivator. Conversely, if Winston shines, starting him could inject new energy into the offense and position Cleveland as a dark horse contender in the AFC.

Fans and analysts alike are divided on the matter. Some view Warner's suggestion as unrealistic, given Watson's pedigree and the Browns' commitment. Others see it as a breath of fresh air, advocating for accountability regardless of status. Social media has buzzed with debates, with hashtags like #BrownsQBCompetition trending as training camp approaches. Former players have weighed in too; for instance, ex-Browns quarterback Bernie Kosar echoed Warner's sentiments, stressing the need for "the guy who's ready to win now."

As the Browns gear up for full training camp in late July, all eyes will be on Watson and Winston. The team's preseason games, starting in August, will provide the first real glimpses of how this competition unfolds under game-like conditions. Stefanski and general manager Andrew Berry face a pivotal decision: stick with the plan or adapt based on performance. Warner's advice serves as a reminder that in the NFL, surprises are the norm, and sometimes the most unexpected path leads to success.

Looking ahead, the resolution of this quarterback battle could define the Browns' 2024 season. A strong start could propel them toward a deep playoff run, leveraging their defensive prowess and offensive weapons. A misstep, however, might lead to another year of what-ifs in a franchise starved for sustained success. Warner's words linger as a challenge: will the Browns have the courage to follow performance over precedent? Only time—and the on-field results—will tell.

In summarizing this unfolding drama, it's clear that the Browns' quarterback situation is more than just a positional battle; it's a microcosm of the high-stakes decisions that shape NFL franchises. With Warner's surprising yet sage advice hanging in the air, Cleveland stands at a crossroads, poised to either reaffirm their faith in Watson or embrace the potential upheaval of starting Winston. Whatever the outcome, this competition promises to be one of the most compelling storylines of the preseason. (Word count: 1,248)

Read the Full Newsweek Article at:
[ https://www.newsweek.com/sports/nfl/browns-qb-competition-sparks-surprising-advice-former-pro-2104807 ]

Similar Sports and Competition Publications

[ Sat, Jul 26th ]: Sporting News

Browns Dillon Gabrielholdssurprisingleadinnotable .. tof Cleveland Q Bcompetition Sporting News Canada

[ Sat, Jul 26th ]: Sporting News

Browns Dillon Gabrielholdssurprisingleadinnotableaspectof Cleveland Q Bcompetition Sporting News

[ Fri, Jul 25th ]: Sporting News

Browns 4- Q Bcompetitionrequiresequipmentguystoplaywidereceiver Sporting News

[ Wed, Jul 23rd ]: Athlon Sports

Josh Allen Backup QB Competition Predicted To Heat Up At Bills Training Camp

[ Sat, Jul 19th ]: Newsweek

Shedeur Sanders Sends Clear Message About Browns QB Competition

[ Sun, Jun 15th ]: Sportsnaut

Shedeur Sanders could be forcing Cleveland Browns' hand in QB competition

[ Thu, Apr 24th ]: bolavip

NFL News: Joe Flacco reveals Kevin Stefanski's ad .. on about Browns QB competition with Kenny Pickett

N※N

Browns QB Competition Sparks Surprising Advice From Former Pro

Browns QB Competition Ignites Debate: Former Pro Delivers Surprising Advice