Colts could add competition for Anthony Richardson, Daniel Jones by trading for Browns quarterback

Published in Sports and Competition on Sunday, August 17th 2025 at 11:50 GMT by The Sporting News
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

The Indianapolis Colts could bring in some more competition for Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones by trading for a quarterback on the Cleveland Browns.

Colts Eye Quarterback Competition to Bolster Anthony Richardson's Development

In the ever-evolving landscape of the NFL, the Indianapolis Colts find themselves at a pivotal juncture with their young quarterback, Anthony Richardson. Drafted as the fourth overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft, Richardson entered the league with immense promise, blending elite athleticism, a cannon arm, and the raw potential to become a franchise cornerstone. However, his rookie season was marred by injuries, limiting him to just four starts before a shoulder issue sidelined him for the remainder of the year. This abbreviated campaign has sparked discussions within the Colts' organization about the best path forward to nurture his growth while ensuring the team remains competitive in the AFC South.

The core of the debate revolves around whether the Colts should introduce legitimate competition for Richardson at the quarterback position. Head coach Shane Steichen, known for his innovative offensive schemes from his time with the Philadelphia Eagles, has publicly expressed confidence in Richardson's abilities. Steichen has highlighted Richardson's work ethic, his quick learning curve, and the flashes of brilliance he displayed in those limited appearances, such as his dual-threat capability that saw him rush for three touchdowns in his brief outings. Yet, the realities of the NFL demand contingency plans, especially for a team that finished 9-8 last season and narrowly missed the playoffs under veteran backup Gardner Minshew.

One proposed strategy is to pursue a seasoned quarterback who could push Richardson during training camp and provide a safety net in case of further setbacks. Names like Ryan Tannehill, a former Pro Bowler with extensive starting experience from his tenure with the Tennessee Titans and Miami Dolphins, have surfaced as potential fits. Tannehill's familiarity with play-action heavy offenses aligns well with Steichen's system, and at 35 years old, he could serve as a mentor without posing a long-term threat to Richardson's starting role. Alternatively, Jacoby Brissett, who has prior experience with the Colts and a proven track record as a reliable bridge quarterback, could return to Indianapolis. Brissett's steady hand and knowledge of the team's culture make him an intriguing option for stability.

The rationale behind adding competition stems from several factors. First, Richardson's injury history underscores the fragility of relying solely on a second-year player. His AC joint sprain not only ended his 2023 season but also raised questions about his durability, given his running style that exposes him to hits. The Colts' medical staff and coaching team are emphasizing techniques to protect him, such as sliding more often and refining his mechanics to avoid unnecessary risks. However, introducing a competitor could accelerate this learning process by creating a high-stakes environment in practice, forcing Richardson to elevate his decision-making, accuracy, and leadership.

Moreover, the Colts' roster is built to win now, with emerging talents like running back Jonathan Taylor, wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr., and a stout defensive line anchored by DeForest Buckner. General manager Chris Ballard has been methodical in his approach to team-building, prioritizing the draft and development over splashy free-agent signings. Yet, the quarterback position remains the linchpin. Last season, Minshew's performance—throwing for over 3,300 yards and 15 touchdowns—kept the team afloat, but his departure to the Las Vegas Raiders leaves a void. Without a capable alternative, the Colts risk derailing their momentum if Richardson struggles early in 2024.

Critics of this approach argue that adding competition might undermine Richardson's confidence, especially for a player still adapting to the professional level after starting only one full season at the University of Florida. His college tape showed a gunslinger with inconsistent footwork and a tendency for turnovers, issues that persisted in his NFL debut. Proponents counter that healthy competition is a hallmark of successful franchises. Look no further than the Green Bay Packers' model with Aaron Rodgers learning behind Brett Favre, or more recently, Jordan Love's patience paying off. The Colts could emulate this by signing a veteran on a short-term deal, allowing Richardson to absorb knowledge while competing for reps.

Financially, the move makes sense. Richardson is on a cost-controlled rookie contract, freeing up cap space—currently around $26 million—for targeted additions. A one-year deal for a veteran like Tannehill or Brissett wouldn't break the bank, estimated at $5-8 million, and could be structured with incentives based on performance. This flexibility also positions the Colts to address other needs, such as bolstering the secondary or adding depth at edge rusher, through free agency or the draft.

From a strategic standpoint, the AFC South is wide open. The Houston Texans have surged with C.J. Stroud, the Jacksonville Jaguars boast Trevor Lawrence, and the Tennessee Titans are rebuilding around Will Levis. For the Colts to contend, Richardson must hit the ground running in 2024. Training camp battles could simulate game pressure, helping him refine his processing speed and pocket presence. Steichen's offense, which emphasizes RPO (run-pass option) plays and deep shots, plays to Richardson's strengths—his 6-foot-4 frame and sub-4.5 speed make him a nightmare for defenses. Yet, without a push, complacency could set in.

Looking ahead, the Colts' offseason workouts and minicamps will be telling. Richardson has been vocal about his rehab progress, sharing updates on social media about his throwing sessions and physical conditioning. Teammates like Pittman have praised his dedication, noting how he's studied film relentlessly to improve his reads. If the team opts against adding competition, they might rely on in-house options like Sam Ehlinger or undrafted free agents, but that lacks the gravitas of a proven NFL starter.

Ultimately, the decision boils down to balancing short-term competitiveness with long-term vision. By introducing a challenger, the Colts could foster Richardson's maturation, turning potential into production. This isn't about doubting their young star but about equipping him with the tools to thrive in a league where quarterbacks are the ultimate difference-makers. As the free agency period heats up, all eyes will be on Ballard and Steichen to see if they pull the trigger on a move that could define the franchise's trajectory for years to come. Whether it's Tannehill, Brissett, or another dark horse, the addition would signal a proactive stance, ensuring the Colts aren't caught flat-footed if history repeats itself with injuries or growing pains. In the high-stakes world of NFL quarterbacking, competition isn't just beneficial—it's essential for forging a champion. (Word count: 912)

Read the Full The Sporting News Article at:
[ https://sports.yahoo.com/article/colts-could-add-competition-anthony-180309090.html ]