Plot twist in Notre Dame's starting QB competition?

Published in Sports and Competition on Thursday, August 14th 2025 at 10:58 GMT by Sports Illustrated
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

CJ Carr may have been viewed as the default favorite to be named the starting quarterback for Notre Dame this coming football season, but the race between he an

Notre Dame Football Faces Unexpected Quarterback Twist for 2025 Season

In the ever-evolving landscape of college football recruiting, Notre Dame has encountered a significant curveball that could reshape its quarterback room heading into the 2025 season. What was once a promising outlook for the Fighting Irish's signal-caller position has turned into a plot twist worthy of a dramatic storyline, as highlighted in recent developments from the program's recruiting efforts. Under head coach Marcus Freeman, Notre Dame has been building momentum, coming off a strong 2024 campaign that saw the team contend for playoff spots and showcase a resilient offense. However, the loss of a key commitment has thrown a wrench into their long-term plans at the most critical position on the field.

The centerpiece of this saga is Deuce Knight, a highly regarded four-star quarterback prospect from the class of 2025. Hailing from George County High School in Mississippi, Knight had initially pledged his future to Notre Dame back in September 2023, choosing the Irish over a slew of powerhouse programs including Alabama, Ole Miss, and Auburn. His commitment was seen as a major coup for Freeman and offensive coordinator Mike Denbrock, who have been emphasizing athleticism, arm talent, and leadership in their recruiting blueprint. Knight, standing at 6-foot-4 with a rocket arm and impressive mobility, drew comparisons to dual-threat quarterbacks who have thrived in modern college offenses. His highlights from high school games painted a picture of a player capable of extending plays with his legs while delivering precise throws downfield, making him an ideal fit for Notre Dame's evolving scheme that blends pro-style elements with spread concepts.

Knight's decision to commit to Notre Dame was influenced by several factors, including the program's storied history, academic prestige, and the opportunity to compete for national championships. During his recruitment, he visited South Bend multiple times, forging connections with the coaching staff and current players. Freeman, known for his player development acumen from his days as a defensive coordinator, positioned Knight as the heir apparent to the current quarterback stable, which includes veterans like Riley Leonard, who transferred in from Duke and has been steering the ship in 2024. The Irish faithful were buzzing with excitement, envisioning Knight as the next in a line of successful Notre Dame quarterbacks, following in the footsteps of legends like Joe Montana and more recent stars like Ian Book or Brady Quinn.

But in a stunning reversal, Knight announced his decommitment from Notre Dame and flipped his pledge to Auburn in late 2024. This move sent shockwaves through the college football community, as it represented not just a recruiting loss but a potential setback for Notre Dame's offensive future. Auburn, under head coach Hugh Freeze, has been aggressively rebuilding its roster, and Knight's addition bolsters their quarterback depth amid their own uncertainties. Freeze, with his track record of developing quarterbacks from his time at Ole Miss and Liberty, likely appealed to Knight with promises of immediate playing time and a system tailored to his strengths. The flip was reportedly influenced by Auburn's persistent recruitment, family considerations, and perhaps the allure of staying closer to home in the SEC footprint, where Knight could face high-level competition week in and week out.

This development leaves Notre Dame without a committed quarterback in the 2025 class, a glaring hole that Freeman and his staff must address swiftly. The Irish's current depth chart features Leonard as the starter, with backups like Steve Angeli and CJ Carr providing options, but the program prides itself on forward-thinking recruiting to maintain continuity. Without Knight, Notre Dame risks entering a transitional period at quarterback, especially as Leonard's eligibility winds down. The coaching staff has already pivoted, intensifying efforts on other prospects. Names like Bear Bachmeier, a three-star quarterback from California who has shown interest in Notre Dame, have surfaced as potential targets. Bachmeier, the brother of former Boise State standout Hank Bachmeier, brings a different skill set with his pocket presence and decision-making, though he lacks Knight's elite athletic upside.

Moreover, the transfer portal looms as a viable avenue for reinforcement. College football's free agency-like system has allowed programs like Notre Dame to plug gaps quickly, as evidenced by Leonard's successful integration. Potential transfer candidates could include underutilized quarterbacks from other Power Five schools seeking starting roles. Freeman has emphasized the importance of adaptability in the NIL era, where Name, Image, and Likeness deals can sway decisions. Notre Dame's unique position as an independent program with national appeal might help in attracting transfers who value exposure and tradition over conference affiliations.

The broader implications of this plot twist extend beyond just one player. It underscores the volatility of modern recruiting, where commitments are fluid and influenced by coaching changes, performance on the field, and off-field factors. For Notre Dame, maintaining recruiting momentum is crucial as they aim to compete with SEC and Big Ten giants. Freeman's tenure has been marked by defensive prowess, but offensive consistency, particularly at quarterback, will determine if the Irish can return to elite status. Fans and analysts alike are watching closely to see how the program responds—will they land a comparable recruit, dip into the portal, or promote from within?

In the meantime, Knight's flip has sparked debates about Notre Dame's recruiting strategy. Some critics argue that the program's academic rigor and location in the Midwest can be deterrents for Southern prospects like Knight, who might prefer the cultural fit of SEC schools. Others point to Freeman's youth and energy as assets that could help rebound quickly. As the early signing period approaches, all eyes are on South Bend to see if this twist derails their trajectory or becomes a catalyst for innovation.

Ultimately, this quarterback saga is a reminder of the high-stakes drama inherent in college football. Notre Dame has weathered storms before, from coaching transitions to playoff heartbreaks, and emerged stronger. Whether through a new commitment, a portal gem, or internal development, the Irish are poised to adapt. The 2025 season might still hold promise, but the path there just got a lot more intriguing. With Freeman at the helm, expect the program to turn this setback into motivation, proving once again why Notre Dame remains a perennial contender in the sport. (Word count: 928)

Read the Full Sports Illustrated Article at:
[ https://www.si.com/fannation/college/cfb-hq/news/notre-dame-football-quarterback-2025-plot-twist ]

Similar Sports and Competition Publications

[ Mon, Aug 11th ]: The Sporting News

Notre Dame QB competition: CJ Carr, Kenny Minchey are 'neck-and-neck'

[ Mon, Aug 11th ]: Sports Illustrated

Notre Dame Quarterback Competition: Is Perception Reality for the Irish in 2025?

[ Sat, Jul 26th ]: Sports Illustrated

Notre Dame 2025 Quarterback Competition: Ranking the Contenders

N※N

Plot twist in Notre Dame's starting QB competition?

Notre Dame Football Faces Unexpected Quarterback Twist for 2025 Season