Jonathan Taylor shares insight on the Colts QB competition

Published in Sports and Competition on Wednesday, August 6th 2025 at 0:38 GMT by WISH-TV
^{🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source}

Colts quarterback battle heats up as Anthony Richardson Sr. and Daniel Jones impress at joint practice with the Ravens in Baltimore.

The Colts' Quarterback Conundrum: Taylor’s Insight into Gardner Minshew and Anthony Richardson

Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor recently offered a fascinating glimpse into the ongoing quarterback competition between veteran Gardner Minshew and rookie sensation Anthony Richardson. In an interview with NFL Network’s Steve Smith Sr., Taylor, known for his candidness and insightful observations, provided valuable context on both players' strengths, weaknesses, and how they are navigating the complexities of vying for the starting role under head coach Shane Steichen.

Taylor emphasized that while Richardson possesses undeniable raw talent – a powerful arm, impressive athleticism, and an exciting potential ceiling – he’s still very much in the developmental stage. He described Richardson as someone who is “learning on the fly,” acknowledging the steep learning curve inherent in transitioning from college to the NFL, especially at the quarterback position. Taylor highlighted that Richardson's biggest challenge isn't necessarily physical; it’s about consistently making the right reads and decisions under pressure, a crucial element of quarterbacking that requires significant mental processing and experience.

The rookie is clearly showing progress, but Taylor stressed the importance of patience and understanding in his development. He pointed out that Richardson’s tendency to try and make highlight-reel plays – using his exceptional athleticism to extend drives or create big gains – can sometimes lead to mistakes and turnovers. Taylor believes that Steichen and the coaching staff are actively working with Richardson on refining his decision-making, encouraging him to take what the defense gives him and prioritize protecting the football.

In contrast, Taylor painted a picture of Minshew as a seasoned professional who brings stability and experience to the Colts’ offense. He characterized Minshew as a “steady hand” and someone who understands how to manage games effectively. Minshew's strengths lie in his accuracy, his ability to quickly process information, and his comfort level within the offensive system. Taylor noted that Minshew is adept at making pre-snap adjustments and getting the ball out efficiently, minimizing sacks and maximizing opportunities for receivers.

Taylor’s comments suggest a nuanced appreciation for both quarterbacks. He didn't explicitly declare a favorite or indicate which player he believes should ultimately win the starting job. Instead, his observations focused on their individual attributes and how they contribute to the team dynamic. He acknowledged that Minshew provides a sense of reliability and predictability, while Richardson offers an electrifying element of unpredictability and potential for explosive plays.

The running back’s perspective is particularly valuable because it comes from someone who directly interacts with both quarterbacks on the field. Taylor's ability to read their intentions and react accordingly gives him unique insight into their strengths and weaknesses. His comments also suggest a positive relationship between the players, emphasizing mutual respect and a shared desire for the team’s success.

Taylor’s remarks implicitly acknowledge the delicate balance Steichen must strike in managing this quarterback competition. The coach needs to provide Richardson with opportunities to gain valuable experience while ensuring that the Colts remain competitive. Minshew's presence provides a safety net, allowing the coaching staff to ease Richardson into the starting role and avoid putting too much pressure on him prematurely.

Furthermore, Taylor’s comments shed light on the broader philosophy of the Colts organization under new ownership and leadership. The emphasis on player development and a long-term vision is evident in their willingness to invest in Richardson's growth, even if it means sacrificing immediate success. The presence of Minshew allows them to maintain a level of competitiveness while nurturing the potential of their future franchise quarterback.

Ultimately, Taylor’s insights offer a more complete picture of the Colts’ quarterback situation than simply focusing on game performance or media speculation. He provides a behind-the-scenes perspective on the players' personalities, work ethic, and how they are contributing to the team’s overall goals. His observations reinforce the idea that the competition between Minshew and Richardson isn't necessarily about one player “winning” over another; it’s about finding the best way to maximize their combined strengths and build a winning foundation for the Indianapolis Colts. The situation is complex, requiring patience, strategic planning, and a commitment to fostering both talent and experience within the team.

Read the Full WISH-TV Article at:
[ https://www.wishtv.com/sports/indianapolis-colts/jonathan-taylor-insight-on-colts-qb-battle/ ]